VCH Piercing Placement Question

I received this message from a woman who has a VCH piercing:

Slightly shallow VCH with curved barI have a well healed vch that is over five years old at this point. I've known from the start that it's a bit on the shallow side, but not extreme shallow. I have a relatively deep hood which can completely cover a q-tip, and the exit point of the vch is maybe 1/8" off from the apex. It looks fine from the front and feels fine, the bottom ball does rest squarely on my clit. The only issue I ever have is that it sometimes likes to pop up like a turkey timer, which can feel a bit odd but doesn't hurt. It's not that it's ever bothered me per say, but I do wonder if I'm missing out on sensation because it doesn't go through the apex and if it would be less inclined to pop up if it did. But I worry about rejection since there's an established fistula from the current piercing so close to where the new one would go. I mean really established; at one point a few years ago, I didn't wear jewelry in it for over a year, yet it never shrunk down past a 16 (was pierced at 14g). So I don't think it will ever close up on me. I also worry a little about the aesthetic of having a hole from the old piercing in front of a new one. Call me vain, but I don't want to ruin the look of things as I happen to be rather a fan of my vulva. Would I likely be running into any problems if I opted for a redo? Am I even really missing out on much since the ball sits where it's supposed to? I don't know if it's worth the effort to try for perfect placement or if I'm splitting hairs with this. What's more important for the sensation, the placement of the bottom ball or the placement through the apex? Thank you so much for your time, A.

My reply:

Hi A.,
If the new position would be within a few millimeters of your existing piercing, I would advise you against repiercing.
J-Curves
Have you considered trying a j-curve as an alternate jewelry style? That shape is likely to produce more sensation than the gentle curve that you're wearing.

Also, it would probably prevent the pop-up phenomenon you're experiencing. Or, you could put a larger ball on the bottom, which should help with the latter issue.

Sincerely,
Elayne

Elayne Angel, Author
The Piercing Bible--The Definitive Guide to Safe Body Piercing
President, Association of Professional Piercers

elayneangel@piercingbible.com
http://piercingbible.com/
http://www.facebook.com/ThePiercingBible
http://twitter.com/elayneangel